Skip to main content
← Back to the library
עברית

More reading: Personal growth and emotional patterns

A person carrying a pile of stones, representing the weight of old patterns

Transference and Countertransference: Why We React Strongly to Certain People

Sometimes what was said just now and what an old relationship taught you to expect sound like the same voice.

Yossi Medalsi, emotional coach specialising in recurring patterns ✓ Reviewed •Updated: 17/11/2026 •3 min read
On this page +

What is transference?

Most of us walk around assuming we respond to what’s happening here and now. But sometimes we respond to a manager, a partner, a friend or a coach through feelings and expectations from an older relationship. That’s called transference.

Sigmund Freud described the phenomenon through his clinical work. A patient might feel anger, admiration or fear of being abandoned by him, sometimes with an intensity that took them by surprise. Freud saw this as a way to understand what the patient had already learned to expect from important relationships.

If you grew up feeling invisible, or believing you had to get everything right to be loved, that expectation can return in your relationships today. You might work too hard, try to please people, or feel hurt when someone doesn’t appreciate your effort, even if they didn’t mean to hurt you.

What does the research say?

In an experiment by Susan Andersen and Alana Baum, participants read a description of someone new. When that person resembled someone important in their lives, participants tended to remember traits that hadn’t been in the description but fit the person they already knew.

Think back to the example of seeking approval. If we’ve learned to expect criticism, we may hear it in a comment that could just as easily mean something else.

This kind of reaction can come up before we understand why we felt hurt or wanted to please someone. Sometimes knowing where it came from still leaves us having the same reaction.

The other side of the coin: countertransference

In psychology, countertransference refers to a therapist’s emotional responses to a patient, including responses shaped by the therapist’s own history. The idea also helps me think about what comes up for me as a coach when I’m sitting with a client.

I see this in my coaching practice. A client might have a strong need for approval, to be liked or to prove their worth. For years my own experience was running things behind the scenes. I was a perfectionist, always trying to prove my worth and giving without asking for anything in return. If I missed that in myself, I might try to rescue the client, please them, or offer the perfect solution so they’d see my worth.

When the client is looking for approval and I’m busy proving my worth, it’s easy to miss what they need from me right then. That’s what I mean when I say old hurts start doing the talking: each of us hears something from an earlier relationship in the conversation we’re having now.

How Heart Compass works with the pattern

The research helps us understand what happens, and understanding alone doesn’t always change how we react. You can read the books, look into attachment theory and see where your difficulties come from, and still find the same reaction coming back when you’re talking to your partner or manager.

In the M.S.A. approach, Map what holds you back means noticing what was said and what it stirred up in you. In Shed the barriers, we make room for the feeling that comes up in the body before rushing to escape, judge or fix it.

Working with the urge to prove your worth and the fear of going unnoticed can give you room to choose. In Advance towards your goals and purpose, that could mean asking your manager what they meant by their comment before rushing to prove you did a good job.

If you recognise a reaction that keeps coming back, the coping styles quiz can help you notice what you tend to do under pressure.

If you recognise the same dynamics in your relationships, you can read more about why we keep taking on the same role.

For more on working with these patterns, see personal growth coaching and the personal growth library.

Frequently asked questions

What is transference? +
Transference is when feelings or expectations from an earlier relationship shape how we understand someone now. A manager’s comment can sound like someone telling us, once again, that we aren’t good enough.
How can I tell if I’m reacting to the present or to an old experience? +
Separate the words that were actually said from the meaning you heard in them. A strong reaction is worth exploring, and it may also make sense given what is happening now. A short follow-up question can help you check what the other person meant.
What is countertransference? +
In psychology it refers to a therapist’s emotional responses to a patient, including responses shaped by the therapist’s own history. In coaching, the idea can help a coach notice what’s come up for them and get back to listening.
If I understand where my reaction comes from, what can I do in the next conversation? +
Choose one conversation where you expect the pattern to appear. When you hear feedback and feel an urge to prove yourself, ask what the other person needs. For example, ‘What’s the most important thing you’d like me to change?’

Sources

When you feel the need to prove yourself again

Bring one moment when a small comment stayed with you. In a first session we can look at what you heard in that moment and what you’d like to do differently next time.

Book an initial session with Yossi