More reading: Personal growth and emotional patterns
Why Do I Compare Myself to My Friends Even When I’m Happy for Them?
I can be glad for my friend and still ask what hurts about their success.
You know the voice. Someone else does well and it has something sour to say. It needs to prove you’re the best in the room. It keeps score, nurses a grudge and always knows whose grass is greener.
Most of us grew up hearing that this voice was an enemy. Call it ego, weakness, a mean streak. The instructions were much the same: beat it. Drown it out with hard work or positive thinking. Stay busy enough and perhaps you won’t hear it. We treat it like a flaw we could sand away.
When a friend succeeds, the first thing you hear may be a verdict on your own life: “I’m falling behind again.” Working with your inner child means going back to those words. When did someone else’s good news start sounding like a judgment on your worth?
Why do I turn on myself when a friend does well?
Sometimes we judge ourselves twice: first for falling behind, then for feeling envious at all. Carl Jung used the term shadow for parts of ourselves we find hard to acknowledge. A friend sharing good news can bring them into plain sight. What do you do with the envy when you really are glad for them?
In “The Philosophical Tree”, Jung argues that coming to terms with our darker side requires bringing it into awareness. In the moment a friend tells you they’ve succeeded, that might mean admitting to yourself that you feel envy before you decide how to respond.
Sometimes the voice keeping score sounds like a child who used to feel invisible. That child is still checking whether there’s room for them, whether anyone sees them at all. It’s worth asking where competition began for you. Everyone has their own answer.
Think of the child shouting to be noticed. Perhaps being competitive once helped you hold on to a place in the group when you were afraid of being left behind.
Scold yourself for feeling envious and a second voice joins in. The first says, “They’ve done better than me.” The second asks, “What kind of friend thinks that?”
In Rita Mae Brown’s novel Sudden Death, a character describes the absurdity of doing the same thing repeatedly and expecting a different result. Here the loop is painfully ordinary. A friend succeeds, I put myself down, and I expect the next round of self-criticism to leave me feeling better.
You can keep fighting that younger part of yourself and hope the next success will finally bring you peace. I think of it as building a palace on sand. No matter how impressive it looks, you still have to worry about the foundations.
How can I accept the envy and still choose how to respond?
In On Becoming a Person, Carl Rogers described a paradox he recognised in his own life. Accepting himself as he was made change possible. With a friend, that might start with an honest admission: “I’m glad for them, and what this brings up in me hurts.”
Change can begin with a different way of looking. Instead of trying to improve the reflection in the mirror, stay with the part that’s hard to see. What am I afraid their success says about me?
If that voice sounds familiar, the coping style questionnaire can help you notice how you tend to respond in moments like this.
Picture sitting down beside that shouting child. You hear the envy and the anger, and this time you stay. Perhaps those feelings once stood guard when nobody else was there. Now there’s room for the child to speak.
In M.S.A. coaching, we trace the moment you stop hearing your friend’s news and start tallying up your own achievements. If what comes up is a fear of being left behind, we can work with that fear at your pace. The next time your friend has news, you might find you can ask how it happened and stay to hear the answer.
The Israeli rock duo Fortisakharof gave me an image I love for that encounter: a dance with something you used to fear.
Once you can hear what that fear is trying to tell you, you may find you can hear a little more of your friend’s story, too.
If you’re tired of the fight, start with one moment when you envied someone you care about. In the M.S.A. approach, we can look at what hurt and how you’d like to respond next time.
Frequently asked questions
Why does fighting my envy seem to make it worse? +
What does accepting myself have to do with change? +
How do I make room for a part of myself I dislike? +
What can I do when my inner critic starts up? +
Sources
- Internal Family Systems Therapy Schwartz, R. C., & Sweezy, M. · Guilford Press · 2019 A clinical model that explores the protective role that critical parts can play.
- Self-Compassion: The Proven Power of Being Kind to Yourself Neff, K. · William Morrow · 2011 A book about self-compassion and responding to harsh self-judgment.
- Homecoming: Reclaiming and Championing Your Inner Child Bradshaw, J. · Bantam Books · 1992 Bradshaw’s account of working with childhood shame and protective habits.
- The Philosophical Tree, in Alchemical Studies (Collected Works, Vol. 13) C. G. Jung · 1967 Jung’s discussion of bringing the darker side into awareness.
- Sudden Death Rita Mae Brown · 1983 A version of the saying appears as dialogue attributed to Jane Fulton in the novel, p. 68. The reference traces earlier variants.
- On Becoming a Person Carl R. Rogers · 1961 The paradox of self-acceptance and change, discussed in “This Is Me”.
When you’re tired of keeping score
Bring one moment when it was hard to be happy for someone close to you. We can explore what hurt and how you’d like to respond next time.
Talk to Yossi about comparison