My Daughter Is Growing Up, and I Find Myself Fighting with Her About Everything
Sometimes an argument about curfew starts with the fear of losing your place in her life.
He said it with a grin, the way everyone else did. “If I ever have a daughter, she’s not leaving her room until she’s twenty.” All the men in the room laughed. He laughed the loudest. I didn’t laugh. I heard something else underneath it.
Seventeen years have passed. His daughter is twelve now. It wasn’t long ago that she sat on his lap watching TV. Now she shuts her door, puts on makeup in front of the mirror, goes out with friends and comes home an hour late. And he finds himself picking fights. About the time. About the length of her shirt. About the way she answers him. About everything.
He came to ask how to get her to listen. I was thinking about a different question. What if the fighting was also about his fear of losing their closeness?
I’ve also written about the moment worry turns into a fight in the parenting library on boundaries and conflict at home.
Something happens in a father’s body at that moment, and it rarely gets talked about. The little girl he knew is becoming someone the world looks at differently. She wants more privacy. Nobody prepared him for that moment, so it feels like a threat.
I sat across from him and wondered where that fear came from, why it seemed so much bigger than what had happened. She was an hour late. And he reacted as if the world were ending.
How do you stay close to your teenage daughter as she gets more independent?
You can agree on a time for her to come home and still give her room to tell you what happened when she’s late. In a study of 101 pairs of sisters, Bruce Ellis and colleagues found that in some of the families studied, better relationships with fathers were associated with less risky sexual behaviour. What stayed with me after talking to this father was whether his daughter would feel able to tell him what happened, even if she knew he was angry.
To start a conversation that doesn’t end with a slammed door, you can use the guide to talking with teenagers to practise listening.
I still wonder what he hoped would happen when he insisted on the curfew. How do you stay close to a daughter who’s starting to ask for more room?
Why can an argument about curfew feel like a fight over the whole relationship?
As long as there’s something to fight about, she still needs his permission. Fighting about the time she came home keeps her close for another moment, even if it hurts them both. The urge to control is an attempt to stop time. The girl who used to sit on his lap is growing up, and he doesn’t know this version of her yet.
“She’s not leaving her room until she’s twenty.” Now the line sounds different. Sometimes the anger that comes out over a shirt or a curfew covers up the hardest thing to say out loud: I’m not ready to give up the place I used to have in her life.
You can read all this, nod along, and still feel your blood rise tomorrow morning when she goes out in that shirt. Understanding only reaches so far. With the M.S.A. approach, we start with what comes up for the father when she’s late. In parent coaching, we work with his fear of losing that closeness. Next time, he can tell her he was worried, ask her to text him if she’s running late, and ask what happened.
I wrote this because I’ve met other fathers like him. Strong, loving men who fight about what time their daughters get home and don’t always realise how much they miss the little girls they used to know. Most thought they were the only ones who felt that way.
Maybe this is the question: who am I willing to be for the daughter she’s becoming, as well as for the little girl she was?
Frequently asked questions
Why do I argue with my teenage daughter about everything? +
How can I stay close to my teenage daughter when she wants more privacy? +
What should I say when my teenage daughter comes home late? +
How can parent coaching help when the same arguments keep coming back? +
Sources
- Impact of fathers on risky sexual behavior in daughters: a genetically and environmentally controlled sibling study Ellis, B. J., Schlomer, G. L., Tilley, E. H., & Butler, E. A. · Development and Psychopathology · 2012 A retrospective study of 101 pairs of sisters that examined quality of fathering in relation to risky sexual behaviour.
- How to Talk So Teens Will Listen & Listen So Teens Will Talk Faber, A., & Mazlish, E. · William Morrow Paperbacks · 2005 A practical guide to listening and talking with teenagers during disagreements.
- Raising an Emotionally Intelligent Child: The Heart of Parenting Gottman, J., & Declaire, J. · Simon & Schuster · 1998 A book on emotion coaching and listening to feelings that come up during conflict.
- You and Your Adolescent: The Essential Guide for Ages 10-25 Steinberg, L. · Simon & Schuster · 2011 A parent’s guide to adolescence, identity and growing independence.
When the arguments with your daughter keep coming back
Bring one argument you remember clearly. We’ll look at what set off the anger and what boundary or conversation you might try next.
Talk to Yossi about what’s happening at home