More reading: Personal growth and emotional patterns
Why Does Overthinking Make Problems Harder to Solve?
You’re still thinking. Are you still learning?
On this page +
- How can I tell when thinking about a problem has stopped helping?
- Why can pressure make it harder to see another option?
- Can stepping away help me solve the problem?
- Why do answers sometimes come in the shower, on a walk or in the car?
- Why does wanting certainty keep me going over the same thing?
- Should I just let it go?
- What keeps me trying the same thing?
- What if the useful question is different?
When something matters, we’re used to trying harder. Think a little longer. Check another option. Analyse the conversation again. Make another plan. If we still don’t have the answer, perhaps we haven’t tried hard enough.
Sometimes the harder we press, the less we see. The mind can get stuck in one way of looking at the problem and keep returning to it even after it stops turning up anything new.
How can I tell when thinking about a problem has stopped helping?
When you’re solving a problem, you look at the evidence, test a different idea and learn from what happens. Rumination can feel just as busy while it keeps bringing you back to the same question, the same explanation and the same search for certainty.
Edward Watkins and Henrietta Roberts reviewed evidence that rumination can interfere with problem-solving and getting things done. It can also make it harder to notice when circumstances change. You’re still thinking. Are you still learning?
Why can pressure make it harder to see another option?
When the outcome matters, the pressure can get in the way of some of the skills you need. A meta-analysis found that acute stress, on average, reduced working memory and cognitive flexibility.
Just when you tell yourself, ‘I have to solve this now,’ it can become harder to hold several options in mind, see the situation from a different angle or try something new.
That helps explain why a bright person can think about a problem for hours and get nowhere. They can still think clearly about many things. This problem has started to look as if there’s only one route through it.
Can stepping away help me solve the problem?
Researchers call it incubation when you set a problem aside for a while and return to it later. Sio and Ormerod’s meta-analysis found that a break can help, depending on the kind of problem and what happens during the break.
In one experiment, Baird and colleagues found that participants who did a simple task that let their minds wander came up with more creative answers to problems they’d already seen. A short break can sometimes loosen the grip of the first idea you got stuck on.
Why do answers sometimes come in the shower, on a walk or in the car?
The water hasn’t got any smarter than you. You’ve simply stopped asking for an answer in exactly the same way. Your attention shifts and you may notice a connection you missed while you were concentrating.
A quiet moment can still be full of thought. Sometimes it gives the pieces a chance to fit together differently.
Why does wanting certainty keep me going over the same thing?
When it’s hard to sit with uncertainty, it’s tempting to look for another sign, another piece of information or one more thing you can do. Research has linked difficulty tolerating uncertainty with less helpful ways of managing emotions.
It’s easy to confuse influence with control. You can influence how you prepare, what you say, what you try and when you change course. Another person’s response, the timing and all the other moving parts remain partly outside your hands.
The more energy you spend trying to force a result, the easier it is to miss information that would help you change direction.
Should I just let it go?
Some problems take time and persistence. One way to tell whether the effort is helping is to ask what you learned that might change what you do next.
Am I finding anything new or repeating the same analysis? Can I consider an option that goes against the answer I want? Is this action moving anything forward, or mostly making it easier to sit with uncertainty?
If you’re seeing no new information and can’t consider a different possibility, another round of thinking may be helping you feel in control for a moment.
What keeps me trying the same thing?
In the M.S.A. approach, I start by asking what’s driving the effort. Are you acting on something you’ve learned? Are you trying to keep a feared outcome from happening?
Suppose you’ve gone over the same conversation again. In ‘Map what holds you back’, you can notice what you’re trying to guarantee. In ‘Shed the barriers’, you can work with the fear of how the other person might respond. In ‘Advance towards your goals and purpose’, you might decide to ask one clear question or wait until you have new information.
What if the useful question is different?
What am I missing while I’m busy trying to make the answer I want come true?
Keep working where you have influence. Listen to what happens when you try something. Give yourself permission to pause when another round of thinking would only repeat the last one.
Frequently asked questions
Can taking a break help me solve a problem? +
How can I tell problem-solving from overthinking? +
Does easing up on control mean giving up? +
Sources
- Does incubation enhance problem solving? A meta-analytic review Sio & Ormerod · Psychological Bulletin · 2009 Meta-analysis of when breaks help problem-solving.
- Inspired by distraction: mind wandering facilitates creative incubation Baird et al. · Psychological Science · 2012 Experiment on a simple intervening task and creative performance.
- The effects of acute stress on core executive functions: A meta-analysis and comparison with cortisol Shields, Sazma & Yonelinas · Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews · 2016 Meta-analysis of acute stress and executive function.
- Reflecting on rumination: Consequences, causes, mechanisms and treatment of rumination Watkins & Roberts · Behaviour Research and Therapy · 2020 Review of rumination and its effects on problem-solving.
- Defining and measuring psychological flexibility: A narrative scoping review Cherry et al. · Clinical Psychology Review · 2021 Review of how psychological flexibility is defined and measured.
- Intolerance of uncertainty and emotion regulation: A meta-analytic and systematic review Sahib et al. · Clinical Psychology Review · 2023 Review of links between intolerance of uncertainty and emotion regulation.
When you keep going over the same problem
Bring a decision or conversation you keep replaying. We can look at what’s keeping the question open and what’s within your reach.
Ask Yossi about personal coaching