More reading: Personal growth and emotional patterns
Why Do I Compare Myself to Others? The Race to Prove My Worth
The same comparison can give us direction or become a measure of our worth.
I’ve always believed that if each of us could live at peace with ourselves, the world would be a quieter place. I came to that through some painful reflection on my own life. When we stop and look inward, we can see how many of the fights going on in our heads begin when we measure ourselves against someone else.
Some of those fights begin in a world that taught us to look for our worth in other people’s eyes, to shrink when someone else succeeds, and to measure ourselves by constantly comparing.
That’s why I chose this work. I wanted to show people how to live at peace with themselves. I’d come to see what a toll it takes when you lose touch with yourself.
Competition is a tricky thing. It can push us beyond what we thought we could do and give us a reason to build or invent something. But when it comes from doubting our own worth, it can become a trap. Life turns into an exhausting race you can never really win, because someone will always be faster or further ahead. Envy, or even hoping someone else will fail, takes energy you could have put into making something of your own.
There’s nothing new about that tension. Think of ancient Rome. Stoic philosophy taught people to focus on what was up to them, while crowds went to the Colosseum to watch gladiators fight. What draws us so intently to the moment when someone else wins or falls?
Sometimes your own standing feels so fragile that seeing someone else lose brings a moment’s relief. They fell and I’m still standing. That relief is brief. It lasts as long as there’s someone else to measure yourself against.
Leon Festinger described how we use other people to evaluate our abilities and opinions. The very same comparison can give us a sense of direction or become a way to judge our worth.
In that kind of race, nothing you do is ever enough. You have to come first because you’re afraid that if someone passes you, you’ll stop mattering.
Carl Jung used the word ‘persona’ for the face we present to society. If it matters to us to look successful all the time, that face can hide how easily we feel small.
This is where René Girard’s idea of mimetic desire comes in, the desires we pick up from other people. When we see someone who seems successful or sure of themselves, we may want what they have because we assume it’s the source of their confidence.
Before we know it, we want exactly what they have. We spend years chasing a job title or a certain standing, only to find that we never wanted it for ourselves. A colleague or a neighbour has become the measure of whether we’re allowed to feel we’re worth something.
You can feel the comparison in your gut. They moved forward and you stayed where you were. Your stomach tightens and you feel the urge to rush out and do something, anything, to silence the alarm.
There’s another way to go about it. Richard Ryan and Edward Deci distinguished between doing something because it interests us and doing it for an outcome separate from the activity itself. We can ask what we find interesting about the work. Someone else’s success might then make us wonder what we could learn from them.
Imagine what would happen if we felt more at home in ourselves, with less need to compete or get even. We’d still have things we wanted to do. We might have more energy to do them.
I’m writing this because I know that race from the inside. Even after years of working on my own patterns, there are still moments when that old competitiveness resurfaces. These days, just before I get pulled back in, I stop. I’m willing to stay with it long enough to meet the child in me who wanted to be seen and feel that he mattered.
In personal growth coaching at Heart Compass, I meet people who are tired of the race. They’ve invested a lot in trying to get out of it and still feel the same emptiness when they see someone else succeed.
Living more at peace with ourselves can start by staying with that tight feeling for a moment and asking what the other person’s success seems to say about us.
In Map what holds you back, go back to the moment a colleague got ahead. What did you see, what did you tell yourself, and what did you immediately want to do? In Shed the barriers, work with the fear of falling behind or going unseen. In Advance towards your goals and purpose, choose a goal you’d want even if that colleague weren’t in the picture, and take one step towards it this week.
It’s time to pause the race. Ask yourself what tightens up inside and see what it’s like to move through the world with a little more peace. You can begin finding your own direction now.
Frequently asked questions
Why do I envy someone else’s success even when I’m doing well? +
Can competitiveness help me grow? +
How can I loosen the habit of comparing myself to others? +
Can I stay ambitious when I stop trying to prove myself? +
Sources
- A theory of social comparison processes Festinger, L. · Human Relations, 7(2), 117-140 · 1954 A theory of how people use comparisons to evaluate their abilities and opinions.
- The relationship of shame, social anxiety and depression: the role of the evaluation of social rank Gilbert, P. · Clinical Psychology & Psychotherapy, 7(3), 174-189 · 2000 Research on links between perceived social rank, shame, social anxiety and depression.
- Self-determination theory and the facilitation of intrinsic motivation Ryan, R. M., & Deci, E. L. · American Psychologist, 55(1), 68-78 · 2000 Distinguishes motivation arising from interest in an activity from doing it for a separate outcome.
- Two Essays on Analytical Psychology (Collected Works, Vol. 7) Jung, C. G. · Princeton University Press · 1966 Jung’s discussion of the persona as the face presented to society.
- Deceit, Desire, and the Novel Girard, R. · Johns Hopkins University Press · 1976 A literary and philosophical account of how others can shape what we want.
When comparing yourself wears you out
Bring one moment when someone else’s success made you feel small, and we can see what you’d like to move towards for yourself.
Talk to Yossi about the pressure to compare